Lately we have seen kids all over the news. They have appeared on CNN, took part in a 2 minutes of hate style (from Orwell’s 1984) town hall where they called a representative from the NRA (Dana Loesch) a murderer and likened a US senator (Marco Rubio) to a school shooter.
Of course these are the same group of kids over and over
again, and they have the same agenda as the mainstream media. They want to
capitalize on the victimhood of these kids to make the public feel sympathy for
their cause: Gun Control.
It is a clever tactic, because who is going to argue with a
kid who has been traumatized, you just end up looking like a bully who does not
care about school shootings. Yet this weaponization of school kids goes too
far.
There are times when the adults need to stand up, put the
kids in time out and tell them they need to be quiet and let the adults talk.
Kids are not possessed of any special expertise or experience except in the realm
of being kids.
Inexperienced and
Short Sighted
The world is a complex place. So complex that adults cannot
even understand the whole of it. Children, having less time and living less
life, have no clue how the world works due to this complexity and lack of
experience.
There is a reason we do not allow children to vote, drink,
go to war, smoke, or enter into legal contracts. They have a hard time
understanding the long term ramifications of these actions not only on their
own life but on the community as well.
This is why we should not take advice from children on how
to act. Sometime children are able to state things clearly and honestly but
this is the exception, not the rule.
Kids, go back to class, put in the time and work and come
back when you actually know what you are talking about. Do not attempt to
lecture me or anyone else on morality or what is right and what should be done.
You are an inexperienced, uneducated child who has lived
under the protection of your parents and those who came before you. Grow up,
stop whining, and show a little respect for the system they built that allows
you to grow up in relative safety and security.
The system is not perfect by any means, but all things
considered it is a better system then what is found in most of the world. If it
were as truly awful as you think or have been told then why do people risk
life, limb, and liberty in an attempt to come here?
The Western World is a light of civilization in a dark
world, a little gratitude for the benefits you gain by being born into this
system would go a long way.
State Sanctioned
Truancy
When these protests and walk outs are planned it is usually
with the consent of the teachers and administrators of the school. We are
paying the state to educate our children and instead they give the kids signs
with slogans on them and tell them to march in the street.
Most kids will see this as a chance to skip class, hang out
with friends and feel good about their virtue signaling. If you ask teenagers
what would they rather do, math, history, and science or go out on the town,
hang out with your friends, and fight for ‘change’ and make the world a ‘better’
place, all without getting into trouble and at the encouragement of their
teachers, which do you think they are going to pick?
Not to mention the fact that these protests are probably not
going to change anything other than missing out on a day of school. We are
living in a world where you need to fill out a permission slip in triplicate and
pay a fee to send your kid to a museum but no such precautions are taken to
allow your children to run around the street of town shouting at people and
getting in the way of traffic.
Publicly Funded
Revolution
I personally do not have children, but I do pay property
taxes. A good portion of those property taxes goes to these schools, which is
fine with me because there can be a public benefit to educating children.
I know I personally do not want my money going to fund these
sort of protests. Do you really want to pay teachers and administrators to, at
best, sit on their hands and do nothing or, at worst, push their own political
agenda?
I want kids to be educated and taught TO think, not WHAT to
think. There is a benefit to educating the public, but there is only harm in indoctrinating
the public.
Child Soldiers
It is clear that these children are being weaponized to push
a political agenda. Kids should not be a political tool to use against your
political opponents regardless of which party you belong to. Some lines should
not be crossed.
These children are human beings, impressionable minds
looking to figure out the world. As such, they have no place in the adult world
of politics. To be clear, I am not saying do not talk to your children about
these things but do not put them in front of a camera and tell them what to say
in order to push an agenda.
Teachers, parents, and the media are all failing these kids
in this regard. Instead of teaching these children how to look at a problem and
work to solve it on their own, they are teaching children that it is okay to
use manipulation of other people’s emotions in order to get what you want.
They are also being taught that if that person does not
immediately give it to you than they are an enemy of yours that truly does not
care for you and is worthy of your hatred and scorn. Sometimes no is one of the
most loving statements you can make to a person.
Children are our future, do not squander that future by
playing political games with them. Let them learn and grow and work out small
things on their own before you tell them they need to go out and be an activist
dead set on fixing the world. Chances are, due to their inexperience and lack
of maturity, they will only make a complex problem worse.
Oof, where to start...
ReplyDeleteIt's pretty ageist to believe that just because someone is younger that they don't have a right to voice their feelings and opinions. Sure, if you are basing life experience on wisdom and knowledge, then it's understandable that someone who is older would have a better understanding, but it's not fair to exclude people for such a reason. If anything, they should be encouraged to speak and enlightened of they misunderstand. Excluding them for age is the same as saying that older people shouldn't be able to voice their opinions because they are probably going to die sooner than the changes they push for can come to fruition.
If you are going to make a blanket statement about what kids will do with their time, we need facts to back it up. I'm middle-aged and would respond the exact same way as these kids you mentioned; I would much rather spend time with friends than going to some institution day in and day out. That doesn't mean our tax dollars are going to waste. That means our education system is failing our children. If children aren't being supported and engaged, then they are likely to cut class. I skipped school and still ended up a full functioning member of society, so I'm sure others can too. If you believe your tax dollars aren't being spent, you can lobby to pay less taxes. You're looking at 25% of your state taxes, which is only ~9% of your income.
I respect your opinions, but I don't agree. I would rather have my children taught to defend themselves and stand up for their beliefs than to lie down and accept whatever comes their way. That's too oppressive.
Thank you so much for the comment and the read.
DeleteI never said that younger people should not have a right to voice their feelings and opinions. I was trying to get across that they can do that but they cannot talk down to adults nor lecture them on what is and is not right.
I think we both agree that most people, including kids would rather spend time with friends than going to class, but I think we both can agree that sacrificing the immediate pleasure of skipping school to hang out with friends will, generally speaking, be a benefit in the mid to long term.
I think that we actually agree more than you think and that communication is the problem here. We both agree that the education system as it is, is failing our children. We both agree that skipping class in itself is not the only indicator that someone will or will not become a full functioning member of society. And we both agree that children should be taught to defend themselves and stand for their beliefs, but that needs to be tempered with the knowledge that you cannot be right 100% of the time and that some things are often way more complex than anyone could think.
Thank you for the civil comment and respectful feedback, you have definitely given me something to consider.